‘American Idol’ judges ‘mortified’ after contestant tells everyone to ‘shut the f— up’

“American Idol” is kicking off its 23rd season with a bang. 

During Sunday’s episode of the singing competition show, judges Lionel Richie, Carrie Underwood and Luke Bryan were left nearly speechless after contestant Sophie Powers – a 20-year-old from Toronto – performed an original song called “STFU.”

Before Powers entered the audition room, Underwood – who won “Idol” in 2005 and has returned to the show two decades later as a judge – spoke about her hopes for the 23rd season. 

CARRIE UNDERWOOD’S JOURNEY TO TRUMP INAUGURATION FROM ‘AMERICAN IDOL’ CHAMP

“I want to see somebody at the end of this thing dominating the airwaves and the charts,” Underwood said. “I want to see a huge artist come out of it.”

Enter Sophie, who kick-started her audition by describing her song as a “tear-jerker.” 

LIKE WHAT YOU’RE READING? CLICK HERE FOR MORE ENTERTAINMENT NEWS

“I had a pet lizard named George / He was cool but he made me really bored,” she began her song. “So I gave him to my mom and she loves him very much because animals are better than people / They tried to cancel me, cancel me / Bother me, bother me / Stop bothering me / I don’t even like my job.”

“Karens, shut the f— up / Vegans, shut the f— up / Babies, shut the f— up / Everyone needs to shut the f— up / Laundry, shut the f— up / War, shut the f— up / Dinosaurs, shut the f— up / Everyone needs to shut the f— up / Traffic, shut the f— up / People, shut the f— up/ Groceries, shut the f— up/ Everyone needs to shut the f— up.”

While the judges were visibly confused, Powers asked Richie how he was feeling. 

“Mortified,” Richie responded.

CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP FOR THE ENTERTAINMENT NEWSLETTER

“My wife will play me that song every evening,” Bryan joked. “You should’ve put ‘Luke, shut the f— up.’”

“You clearly have a thing going,” Underwood said. “You’re interesting. Obviously, in the context of ‘American Idol,’ I don’t know where you would fit in here.”

“Neither do I, I’m literally Canadian,” the singer-songwriter responded.

With three “No’s”, Powers thanked the judges before leaving the room. 

Viewers were quick to share their thoughts on the unique audition. 

“When her parents told her, ‘Sophie, just be yourself,’ Sophie took that as a challenge,” one viewer commented on YouTube. “Loved this audition, and loved her. I wish they had let her go to Hollywood, just so I can see what she would sing next.”

“She’s gonna be the most famous from this season,” another wrote. 

This post was shared from Fox News.

The Fox News Channel (FNC), commonly known as Fox News, is an American multinational conservative news and political commentary television channel and website based in New York City, U.S. It is owned by Fox News Media, which itself is owned by the Fox Corporation. It is the most-watched cable news network in the U.S., and as of 2023 it generates approximately 70% of its parent company's pre-tax profit. The channel broadcasts primarily from studios at 1211 Avenue of the Americas in Midtown Manhattan. Fox News provides a service to 86 countries and territories, with international broadcasts featuring Fox Extra segments during advertising breaks. Last updated from Wikipedia 2025-03-13T10:58:55Z.
Wide Variation in Reliability
Strong Right
Take-Down Requests
If you represent the source for this content and would like us to remove this from our site, please submit a takedown request above and we will review it promptly.
Something here about the community discussion ground rules. Recently updated charts from the most popular data releases according to the Federal Reserve Economic Database (FRED).
…..comments widget will be down here.
Recently updated charts from the most popular data releases according to the Federal Reserve Economic Database (FRED).